Torchwood Dilemma (as handed out in class)
Response #2: 50 pts.
Due: Wednesday, July 16th– paper copy in class, Turnintin.com by 11:59 pm. Weds
Directions:
Respond to ONE of the following question in a typed, MLA formatted
document. Your thoughtful and full
response should be 350-750 words (1-2 pages).
- Jack and Ianto confront the 456, saying that “An injury to one is an injury to all,” and in effect declaring war on the alien. This is also known as the doctrine of Absolutism; however, this action results in the deaths of many people stationed at Thames House. Was this an act of arrogance, or were they making a defensible stand? Explain your answer.
- During the secret government discussions, it is suggested that the government “spin” the story of the missing children as a potentially “good thing.” The resources of the earth are dwindling while the population continues to grow. Losing 35 million children might ease the burden on the planet. This is known as Darwinism. In Current Issues, Hardin argues: “Every human born constitutes a draft on all aspects of the environment: food, air, water, forests, beaches, wildlife, scenery, and solitude….If we satisfy a growing population’s need for food, we necessarily decrease its per capita supply of the other resources needed by men” (408). Is this a defensible position? Why, why not?
- The world governments ultimately decide that they have no choice but to comply with the 456 and make plans to give them the children, thus endorsing the position of sacrificing the one for the many. This is known as Relativism or Utilitarianism. Was this decision correct? Can you think of any other options? Explain your answer.
- Three Letters (to an Ethicist) - Randy Cohen, pg 425-427. Instead of analyzing the argument as you would with the Reading Log format, please look at Topics for Critical Thinking and Writing on pg 427, which is a set of proposed letters to Mr. Cohen. Please answer either #2 or # 6. In your response, be sure to address all the issues under consideration and then propose your answer. Include your reasons for your answer. This should be 300 - 700 words ( 1 - 2 pages)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.